Umlaut-Grumpiness Connection Myth Debunked

I sent an email to David Myers asking him about the umlaut article.  Prof. Myers was kind enough to send me the following response:

This is a misreported story that took on a life of its own.  I’ve never done research on German speech and personality (this was an utterly mistaken press report misattributed to me that has recycled for several years).  But here is what I do report in my introductory psychology text:

Saying the phonemes e and ah, which activate smiling muscles, puts people—believe it or not—in a better mood than saying the German ü (rather like saying the English e and u together), which activates muscles associated with negative emotions (Zajonc & others, 1989).

Zajonc, R. B., Murphy, S. T., & Inglehart, M. (1989). Feeling and facial efference: Implications of the vascular theory of emotions. Psychological Review, 96, 395–416.

Let us set the record straight.  The original press report was unreliable, Professor Myers does not stand for the proposition that frequent pronunciation of umlauts "causes German grumpiness."  He has only cited, in passing, a study that appears to support a much more limited proposition.  If I didn’t have a day job, I might actually want to track down the Inglehart & Murphy article.

The decision to wait and see whether I could find out more about this theory has paid off.  I believe this is the first time anything approaching journalism has ever been committed on German Joys.  I promise it won’t be the last!

4 thoughts on “Umlaut-Grumpiness Connection Myth Debunked

  1. A quick ad-hoc one-person study leads me to the opinion, that one (me) can say ‘ü’ not only with the lips in a ‘just ate a lemon’ position, which may be ‘associated with negative emotions’, but also (what I do usually) in a ‘kissing’ position , the same I use for ‘u’. That actually makes saying ‘ü’ somewhat funny, and I never heard of kissing as a ‘negative emotion’. So the original study may be linking one lip position with emotions, but I doubt it applies to every speaker of ‘ü’. (‘ö’ on the other hand feels worse (like the first version of ‘ü’), and it happens to be a ‘you got me, I can’t answer this question’ sound possibly associated with embarrassing situations ..).

    Like

  2. Oh dear lord. After living in Germany for several years and doing what I can to learn the language…my lord, I’ve stumbled upon the secret to my Deutsche issues!

    Ever catch that essay by Mark Twain on his forays into German?

    Like

  3. Off topic, but can I just say how fantastic this blog is? I just love these little gems of German culture, and the German word of the week is helping beef up my poor vocabulary.

    Danke dir!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s