Returning Veterans

Ed Philp with a far-flung rumination on the US, hoping to provoke Andrew into a comment at some point during his vacation.

I read a lengthy profile of women veterans returning back to the United States this weekend in the NYT Magazine (article here). The article made me recall a thought I had a while back in 2004 or 2005. The United States now has around 130,000 service members stationed in Iraq, and it’s probably safe to assume that in total, some 200,000 will have rotated in and out since the beginning of the war in 2003.

It is trite to say it, but these people will have had remarkably different experiences than the vast majority of Americans their age. Some of them will have shot people; others will have watched friends die or Iraqis murdered; most will have experienced a genuine fear for their lives and – at the least – seen things that ‘stateside’ civilians only read about in the newspaper, if at all.

Will there be a long-term effect of having a group of people reintegrate back into US civil society having participated in a real shooting war, and having seen and done things that the mainstream can only witness in an abstract manner? Some of these people will be psychologically damaged, others crippled; all of them will likely feel themselves to be once-removed from the others who did not go through this experience. For some, it may be a transformative experience that is profoundly positive.

It has been argued that returning veterans from World War II made a significant contribution to the US post-war industrial boom, as a generation returned from war disciplined, trained in organizational staffing and logistics, and well-suited for the hierarchies of the business world. Vietnam perhaps had the opposite effect, with thousands of veterans returning home disillusioned, exposed to mindless brutality, drugs, and defeat (obviously, not all Vietnam veterans would agree with that).

There is no doubt that participation in either World War II or Vietnam became a touchstone issue for a generation – as an example, witness the emphasis given to the military service credentials of presidential candidates, to John F. Kennedy, or George H.W. Bush; witness also the the recurring focus on the service in Vietnam of candidates such as Kerry and McCain (or lack thereof for George W. Bush).

In twenty years, will service in Iraq today be such a focal issue in American politics? Will the returning veterans from Iraq today go on to have a disproportionate positive or negative influence within US society? For the US, World War II and Vietnam were common denominators for generations of young men who were drafted or volunteered en masse. This is not the case with Iraq: the returning veterans won’t represent a general majority among their age group anywhere. Nonetheless, they are sitting in college classrooms now, and more are on the way; many are approaching the age where they will assume responsibility in civil positions in society; some will go on to start businesses, attend medical school, run for office. Is this noticeable in the US?

One thought on “Returning Veterans

  1. Hi, I am a German Citizen and Soldiers’ Angel of the Soldiers’Angels Organization. Yes, I live in Germany and I am in charge of Soldiers’Angels Europe which just launched a couple of days ago.

    As a German Civilian I have a lot of insight of what is going with those serving on the Frontline. The experiences I made are difficult to describe because you just can’t put it into words.

    All I know is, that it is important to the Soldiers to have contact to the outside world. In the past two years I’ve been in contact with many Americans, British and Canadians as well as Dutch Soldiers and most of these contacts turned into a very close friendship that stands anything and everything. You can compare them to the friendship and camraderie between Soldiers.

    That is because someone cares. You wouldn’t believe of what a handwritten letter means to them. What a simple conversation via email can do and of how much they enjoy packages and postcards from home.

    These things help them through the deployment. I’ve had several Soldiers that wanted to kill themselves and we kept them going. With every letter and email they knew that there is someone out there, a stranger who cares.

    These Strangers, also called Soldiers’ Angels, know more about the war and of what a Soldier is going through than anyone else because we live with the direct memories of deployed Soldier. Live with all the knowledge of what they are going through. They mostly don’t tell the families because they would be to scared, but they tell us of what is going on (no classified information of course), and we live with it, day by day. If we are in the Wounded TLC we also live with that. I’ve seen wounded, talked to them personally, saw the arrivals of woundeds… you don’t have to be American to get an insight. It simply takes a German Soldiers’ Angel. And I’m telling you, it is addictive. Once you’ve started and received the first letter, handwritten by a Soldier from the Frontline, if in Afghanistan or Iraq… you won’t be able to stop, because you see that they truly need us.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.